- Mrs. Osmond Theatre Reviews
“The Finellis is a toe-tapping musical … Mark Janicello reprises his movie role of (Tony) Finelli, with booming vocals which are rich beyond the demands of the score. Anna María and Pippa Juilet are certainly to be celebrated as they provide some of the best performances of the night, with fantastic vocals and committed performances. Show stand outs include a lovely scene between nightclub owner Eva (Markie Thompson) and Tony Finelli, where she helps him come to terms with the way things have changed in the 15 years since his incarceration. Similarly, a scene between father and daughter wows the audience with a fantastic vocal performance...”
– Adventures in Theatreland
“There's no question that Mark Janicello has a stunning voice, ...Anna María manages to shine throughout as Lola Finelli - an incredibly talented performer, she makes the material work for her and never once gives less than 100%.”
- London Theatre Reviews
"The main highlight of The Finellis Musical is solid vocal performances from all the cast... Markie Thompson gives a wonderful performance as Eva Klein, effervescent nightclub owner, with an exciting rendition of The Woman in the Mirror, a moving LGBTQ+ anthem."
- The Reviews Hub
"An operatically trained tenor, Janicello has a powerful voice that Weidmann’s music allows him to show off."
- Musical Theatre Reviews.com